Updated
Birth injuries and medical negligence: why a diagnosis is not proof.
Families often arrive here with one question: was this preventable? This section explains, in general terms, how that question is actually answered, what a legal review looks at, and why the honest answer is almost never available from a website.
Three different things that are easy to confuse
- A condition. Cerebral palsy, HIE, a brachial plexus injury. A diagnosis describes what is happening in your child's body.
- A cause. Why it happened. Many birth-related conditions have several possible causes, some of them arising before labor began, and in some cases no cause is ever identified.
- Negligence. A legal conclusion that care fell below the standard a reasonably careful clinician would have met, and that this shortfall caused the harm. It requires the full record, qualified medical experts and the rules of your state.
A website can explain the first. It cannot determine the second or the third for your child, and any site that implies it can is not being straight with you.
What this section covers
How a medical negligence review generally proceeds and where state rules change it; which medical records matter and how to obtain them; what to ask an attorney in a free consultation; and a glossary of the terms you will hear. Every legal guide is held for attorney review before it is published, and no state-specific deadline or rule appears on this site until it has been reviewed by an attorney licensed in that state. Our state framework explains why.
If you want to talk to someone now: consultations with birth injury attorneys are commonly free, and a good attorney will tell you honestly when they do not see a claim. Here is how our service works and where it stands.